How to Create a Retail Loyalty Program for Your Store
In episode 15, I explain how a retail loyalty program can support repeat visits and share ways to design one that fits your customers and your store.
Have you ever gotten a free drink at Starbucks, earned cash back at Target, or paid a lower price for an item at Ikea? If so, you’ve experienced the joy of a retail loyalty program.
Retail loyalty programs are valuable to consumers because they get free items, discounts, or special offers. But for independent retailers, offering a rewards program can give you valuable insights into your customers’ buying habits, retain the customers who are most likely to buy from you again, and boost your bottom line.
Keep reading to learn why a retail loyalty program is a smart move for your store and how to implement one in your indie retail business.
Repeat customers are part of your “hot” audience. They’re already familiar with you, and you know that they like what you have to offer. To keep a hot lead from turning into a cold one, you need to get them to return to your store and make more purchases.
So how can you keep your hot customers from turning cold and generate more income for your business? By creating a retail loyalty program.
What is a Retail Loyalty Program?
Simply put, a retail loyalty program is a way to encourage customers to continue to shop with you.
On a deeper level, your retail loyalty program is a key piece of your marketing toolbelt. Having a loyalty or rewards program is a smart marketing strategy! But designing an effective program takes planning—there isn’t a one-size-fits-all approach that works for every independent retailer.
Let’s look at the nitty-gritty of how you can create a retail loyalty program that works for your store and gets customers to come back again and again.
Why Your Indie Retail Store Needs a Loyalty Program
In a 2024 case study from Snappy, 76% of American consumers reported spending more money when part of a retail loyalty program. In addition, having a loyalty program not only incentivizes customers to return, but can be the very reason that customers choose your store in the first place.
Use your store’s reports to understand how often customers return and how much they spend. That gives you a starting point for evaluating your loyalty program.
If you think about the places you shop, such as your local grocery store, Target, or Starbucks, you’re probably already part of a retail loyalty program. Who doesn’t want a free frappucino after a certain number of purchases?!
How to Design Your Boutique’s Loyalty Program
While larger retailers can afford to have smart phone apps for their loyalty programs, you don’t need to get quite so technically advanced. You can design a simple, effective, and revenue-generating retail loyalty program for your indie retail store—let’s dive into how.
Identify Your Ideal Customer
For your retail loyalty program to be effective in retaining and rewarding repeat customers, it needs to be appealing to them! If you don’t understand your ideal customer, they might be turned off by the rewards you choose to offer.
In addition to understanding your customers, take a look at the data from your sales system. Look for what products sell well, then try to pinpoint why those products are popular.
You can also sift through your data to understand your customers’ spending habits and buying trends. Some point of sale systems are able to run these reports for you, so be sure to look into the reports available to you.
Set Goals for your Retail Loyalty Program
Next, consider why you want to set up a retail loyalty program.
Do you want your customers to spend more? Do you want more repeat customers? Do you want them to sign up for your email list? Or do you want their information so you have more data about your typical customers and what they buy?
All of those are valid reasons from which you could create a goal for your program. Consider setting goals related to how many customers you want to sign up for your program, how many repeat customers you have in the next quarter, or how much your email list grows after starting your loyalty program.
Choose What Type of Retail Loyalty Program You’ll Offer
There are lots of options for your loyalty program! You could base it on quantities of certain products, create a points accrual system, or focus on the dollar amount spent by each customer.
These options might seem better or worse to you depending on the type of retail store you own. For example, a coffee or cupcake shop might base their rewards on quantity—for every six you buy, get one free.
A gift shop might choose a dollar amount program. When a customer spends $100, they get a $10 store credit. The possibilities are endless!
You should offer rewards that are a) attractive to your ideal customer, b) easy to redeem, and c) easy for you and your staff to communicate. Keeping it simple will encourage customers to participate and make it more rewarding for everyone.
Digital vs. Paper: Retail Loyalty Program Options
There are a lot of software programs and point of sale systems that have integrated retail loyalty programs, but some independent retailers prefer an analog rewards system.
Inside Master Shopkeepers, there are store owners who prefer pen and paper order forms, spreadsheets over bookkeeping software, and manual cash registers instead of a point of sale system. As long as your system makes sense to you and is easily explained to your staff, you can absolutely do a pen and paper retail loyalty program.
Design-It-Yourself Rewards Card
If you prefer a traditional pen and paper system, design a rewards card for your store and print it on card stock. The original episode mentioned a member Canva template. Check your current member resources for available templates.
Using your POS System’s Built-In Rewards Program
Most point of sale systems offer a digital rewards program, however, it’s often a paid service or add-on.
For example, Square offers an integrated retail loyalty program based on dollar values or points. The system tracks all of the information using the customer’s cell phone number, updates the customer via text with their points information after a transaction, and even sends the customer a reminder to let them know when their points are expiring.
Adding a Rewards App or Plugin to Your POS System
Some POS systems don’t have a built-in rewards program, but they do allow for 3rd-party apps or plugins.
With Shopify, you can create a robust POS system curated to your needs with the addition of apps. Each app provides a different tool/system that helps you improve your sales, refine your marketing, or create a retail loyalty program.
Although there are lots of free apps available, many come at a price. The better the service of the app, the more it will cost you.
Reward Your Best Customers With a Loyalty Program for Your Indie Retail Store!
A loyalty program needs to fit your margins, your customers, and the time your team has to manage it. Start with rewards you can sustain and review whether the program supports repeat visits.
With a well-designed retail loyalty program, both you and your customers win! You gain valuable insights that help you enhance your marketing strategies, and your customers have an incentive to remain loyal to your indie retail store.
Resources
- Episode 12: Social Media Ads 101
- Episode 09: How Well Do You Know Your Retail Customer?
- Join Master Shopkeepers, a territory-protected retail training mastermind! You’ll get access to valuable lessons & resources, coaching calls, and a vibrant community of your fellow store owners cheering you on.
Timestamps
- [04:40] What is a Retail Loyalty Program?
- [05:39] Why Your Indie Retail Store Needs a Loyalty Program
- [06:57] How to Design Your Boutique’s Loyalty Program
- [09:46] Digital vs. Paper: Retail Loyalty Program Options
- [15:46] Reward Your Best Customers With a Loyalty Program for Your Indie Retail Store!
Connect With Kathy
Kathy Cruz is an Independent Retail Coach who helps store owners work smarter, profit more, and grow their brick and mortar businesses.
Connect with Kathy and learn more here:
Website: www.savvyshopkeeper.com
Instagram: @savvyshopkeeper
Mastermind Group: Master Shopkeepers






